90
[Sport-Name-First/Second/ThirdTeam-Position]
1975
Football Tony Winter 2 LB
1976
Football Tony Winter 1 LB
1979
Men's Basketball John Whitmer 1 C/F
1980
Men's Basketball Brian Cozzens 3
Men's Basketball Ed Henninger 3
1981
Baseball Mike Yohe 2 2B
Men's Basketball Brian Cozzens 1 F
1982
Football Dave Butler 1 DL
Football Dave Schanbacher 2 C
Men's Basketball Brian Cozzens 2 F
1985
Baseball Barry Kerr 1 IF
1987
Baseball Rodney Gross 2 OF
1989
Softball Beth Finkey 1 C
1991
Baseball Mike Dallas 2 SS
1992
Baseball Mike Dallas 1 SS
Men's At-Large Randy Lowe 1 CC/Track
1993
Women's At-Large Joy Motter 2 Tennis
1994
Football Joel Yohn 1 K
Women's At-Large Cindy Kepler 1 Swimming
1995
Baseball Tut Bailey 1 DH
Football Chris Bickel 2 DB
Football Joel Yohn 1 K
1997
Women's At-Large Danielle Argento 2 Lacrosse
Women's At-Large Stacy Bryner 3 Field Hockey
1998
Women's At-Large Danielle Argento 1 Lacrosse
1999
Women's Basketball Ashley Totedo 2 F
2002
Women's At-Large Page Heath 3 Lacrosse
2003
Football John Kuhn 1 Fullback
Men's Track & Field/Cross Country Justin Gindlesperger 3 Track & Cross Country
Women's At-Large Page Heath 3 Lacrosse
2004
Football John Kuhn 1 RB
Women's At-Large Page Heath 1 Lacrosse
Women's Track & Field/Cross Country Kelly Stewart 2
2005
Softball Elizabeth Corr 3 OF
Softball Anna Corr 3 IF
Softball Jaime Dacey 1 OF
2006
Men's At-Large Corey Jacoby 2
Softball Heather Chantiles 1 OF
2008-09
Women's Track & Field/Cross Country Mary Dell 1
2009-10
Women's Track & Field/Cross Country Mary Dell 1
Women's Track & Field/Cross Country Neely Spence 3
2010-11
Women's At-Large Kristen Brooks 1 [FH]
Women's At-Large Amy Fisher 3 [WSWIM]
Men's Track & Field/Cross Country Bryan Beegle 2
Women's Track & Field/Cross Country Neely Spence 2
2011-12
Women’s At-Large Kristen McCandless 1 [WSWIM]
Football Mike Frenette 2
Men’s Basketball John Corrigan 3
Men’s Track & Field/Cross Country: Stephen Schelander 1
Women’s Track & Field/Cross Country: Neely Spence 1
Men’s Track & Field/Cross Country: Bryan Beegle 2
Women’s Track & Field/Cross Country: Sara Wagner 3
2012-13
Football Mike Frenette 2
Baseball Pat Kregeloh 3
Men’s Track & Field/Cross Country Joel Flott 2
Women’s Track & Field/Cross Country Katie Spratford 2
2013-14
Volleyball Jill Edwards 1
Softball Hilary Lyons 2
Baseball Pat Kregeloh 3
Women's At Large Bre White 2 [FH]
Women's Track & Field/Cross Country Megan Lundy 2
2014-15
Women's At-Large Lucy Kauffman 1 [FH]
Women's Track & Field/Cross Country Megan Lundy 2
Men's Track & Field/Cross Country Ryan Spangler 3
2015-16
Women's At-Large Rikki Sargent 3 [WSWIM]
Men's At-Large Stefan Szilagyi 3 [MSWIM]
Women's Track & Field/Cross Country Megan Lundy 1
Men's Track & Field/Cross Country Caleb Bartlett 2
2016-17
Men's Track & Field/Cross Country Caleb Bartlett 1
Men's Track & Field/Cross Country Tim Usher 3
Women's Track & Field/Cross Country Casey Norton 3
2017-18
Football Colin McDermott 1
Football Ryan Zapoticky 2
Men's Track & Field/Cross Country Alex Balla 3
2018-19
Baseball Jack Goertzen 1
Women's At-Large Valerie Hertz 3 (Lacrosse)
2019-20
Women's At-Large Gracee Tothero 3 (Women's Swimming)
Men's Track & Field/Cross Country Tommy Haas 3
2020-21
Softball Hannah Marsteller 1
Men's Track & Field/Cross Country Alec Stimson 3
2021-22
Football Trey Paul 1
Football Brycen Mussina 2
Softball Hannah Marsteller 1
Women's At-Large Tori Albright 2 (Field Hockey)
Women's At-Large Jazmin Petrantonio 3 (Field Hockey)
Women's At-Large Jenna Sluymer 3 (Field Hockey/Tennis)
Men's Track & Field/Cross Country Chayce Macknair 2
2022-23
Women's Track & Field/Cross Country Leah Graybill 1
Men's Track & Field/Cross Country Chayce Macknair 3
2023-24
Women's Track & Field/Cross Country Leah Graybill 3
2024-25
Women's At-Large Emma Albee 3 (Field Hockey)
